General Discussion > Small talk

Quotes: Algorithmic Semantics

(1/1)

Kilian:
A lot of the sentences you come across is simply nonsense and you have to make sense of them.

a. If she has an essay to write she will study late in the library.
b. She will study late in the library.
c. She has an essay to write.
In an experiment by Byrne, 71% of the participants said c follows from a and b. Aleks is surprised that the number isn't even higher.
Anas: I would go a step further and say they're right.

Even if you throw an atomic bomb, the non-effects are vastly greater than the effects.

Laura:
Aleks is right about them being right. Pragmatics says that in this context the if must be read as an iff, else the information in (a) would not be relevant with respect to the information in (b).

Navigation

[0] Message Index

Go to full version